Feedback on our indie artist

Today we received feedback on the work we had done on our Indie artist, here are the responses from members of our class + target audience.

Positives
+ Good Market Research (twice)
+ Lots of Piccys! :)
+ Good work on tour artwork
+ Love the use of inspiration
+ Nice highlighting & images
+ Awesome detail.. So much detail.
+ You've really gone all out!
+ Good CD artwork and photo stuff. :)
+ 8/10, would read again
+ Very nice
+ Good Research

Negatives
- Not an Indie name
- Too long
- Mainstream idea (name + logo)
- Doesn't have an Indie feel

Although mostly positive feedback, I am disappointed with some of the negative feedback as I don't feel they are justified.